?

Log in

Previous Entry | Next Entry

two years on, still doing battle...

So it's been almost two years since I've been on here. Not very much has changed for me, and I still participate in fandom some, just not on here. But doing battle with a Rose hater just now on another site ignited my desire to return here, LOL. I still don't write fic, but meta and episode discussion/analysis are still decent fun. But Doctor Who and I these days... well, that's a different story.

Remember how excited I was by Peter Capaldi taking over the Doctor? Yeah... that didn't last.

I hate Twelve. I say that unequivocally. I watched "Deep Breath" and "Into the Dalek" when they aired, but I stopped after that, initially. The weeks passed, I was too busy to watch, and the episodes started piling up... and I realized I didn't care. I didn't care enough to continue watching. And more than that, the more time that went on and the more things I saw from the episodes I wasn't watching, the more I realized I hated Twelve.

This was the start of it. This was why it continued.

The remarks about Clara's appearance--those hurt. I've struggled with my body image my whole life, with no cause, many have said. I'm skinny, so to many my problems don't exist (I've been told that, that since I'm skinny I must not have any other problems with my body). But I've been called ugly and other things to my face, and complimented on my appearance only once. That sort of thing leaves a mark. So to see it perpetuated by the Doctor left me feeling sick.

To see the Doctor turning into the sort of abusive, bullying prick who needed to be the most important person in Clara's life, despite not deserving that distinction, made me sour towards him even more. I remember that when Clara blindly put out her hand in "Deep Breath," I did not expect Twelve to come back for her. That was when I realized I didn't trust Twelve. That was why I was glad when Clara decided she didn't feel safe enough to travel with him--"I don't think I know who you are anymore." I certainly didn't know that, either. So when Moffat had Eleven pull a guilt trip from beyond the grave to make her travel with Twelve? You can imagine how disgusted I felt.

I've now seen through "The Caretaker," as I eventually decided to watch Series 8 to see if it was as bad as I'd figured (spoiler alert: it is). I'll be watching the rest of the episodes soon. But I wanted to revive my journal here because I miss discussions, and I miss the glory days, really. Watching Twelve makes it hit me more than anything that I don't recognize the Doctor anymore. The Doctor who immediately forgets the names of acquaintances is not the same Doctor who apologized to the body of a man whose name he didn't even now, in "World War Three", the same Doctor who regretfully asked a bus full of tourists what the Hostess' name was--and realized none of them knew. The Doctor who insults Clara's appearance and intelligence needlessly is not the same Doctor who called Rose "beautiful" or Donna "lovely."

I recognize my feelings about Twelve and my discomfort with Twelve and Clara's relationship are not shared by everyone; in fact, some I follow still from the Doctor/Rose days ship them. If you like either Twelve or the relationship, feel free to disregard or unfriend me. I'm pretty consistently negative in that regard and I don't foresee the situation getting any better. But if you feel the same way I do, I'd love to talk.

So for now, I'm back. I won't be writing fic, though sometimes I've thought about it (Rose wouldn't recognize this Doctor, either; thinking of her giving him a good chewing out makes me happy). But I'll be my usual overly analytical self if any of you are still around to listen.

Hi again, all. :)

Love,
Trai

Tags:

Comments

( 2 comments — Leave a comment )
develish1
Jul. 20th, 2015 12:47 am (UTC)
I'm still lurking around, though as you can see from how long it's taken me to comment I'm not always terribly up to date with my f-list, lol.

As for DW, my head canon basically stops before Eleven appeared (I disliked him immensely almost from the minute he appeared), and sadly Twelve has done nothing to really change my view. I've seen every episode after a fashion, though I really can't say I watched them, as most were half viewed over the top of my laptop screen while doing something more entertaining.

I still read fic (assorted pairings as always but again nothing really post Ten's era) and occasionally still write, though the same rule applies.

So yeah I'm still here, and happily living in denial, lol
redknightalex
Jul. 27th, 2015 07:38 pm (UTC)
I've been thinking along the same lines, mostly the "good old days" or hanging out around LJ, having discussions, enjoying people, and not worrying what other stupid things Moffat can do to (imho) ruin the good Doctor's name. Hit me the other day when I decided on an awful pain-day that I needed some good comfort TV and watched Series 2 again because, well, reasons. Made me miss a lot of things, just as you said.

I've tried watching Twelve, mostly because a good friend of mine is a big Whovian (even got her to watch some of the Classic stuff) and she enjoyed Eleven. We watched some of the Twelve episodes but he was just too rude, even in the beginning, and so awful to Clara that I didn't understand why anyone would trust him. *shrug* I haven't watched as far as you because, sort of like Twelve, my wonder is gone and I'd rather watch something from the '70s than this. A Doctor without wonder or compassion is NOT the Doctor.

Anyway, stopping by to say, yeah, I hear ya.
( 2 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

July 2015
S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Lilia Ahner